The Traitors: New Blood Has A Big Problem To Fix Before Season 2

The Traitors: New Blood renewed for Season 2

Fans of Traitors: New Blood watched as the finale revealed the winner of the first ever all civilian season. After watching for weeks as regular people from around the United States battled for a cash prize of over $200,000, the show announced that there will be a Season 2 of New Blood, but there is one problem that needs to be fixed before the show returns for a second installment.

There is no denying that the celebrity version of The Traitors has become one of reality television’s most entertaining competitions. Between the ruthless betrayals, explosive roundtable confrontations, suspicious alliances and contestants who seem perfectly comfortable throwing their fellow players under the bus, the Peacock series has established a pretty high bar.

Unfortunately, New Blood hasn’t always managed to capture that same energy. The show needs more drama. And while bringing everyday Americans into the competition was an interesting way to expand the franchise, some viewers have questioned whether the civilian contestants have delivered the same level of cutthroat gameplay that made the original such a success.

With Season 2 now confirmed, NBC has an opportunity to fix that.

The Traitors: New Blood star Victor
Image: NBC/YouTube

The Traitors: New Blood Needs More Ruthless Players

One of the biggest appeals of The Traitors is watching contestants attempt to outsmart one another while trying to convince everyone else that they are trustworthy. The celebrity players know how to play up the drama, most having been part of other reality TV franchises in the past.

It’s a game built around deception, manipulation and strategic thinking. Being nice to everyone might make someone popular in the castle, but it isn’t necessarily going to help them win a competition in which someone could be secretly plotting their murder before breakfast. That’s where New Blood has sometimes struggled to deliver.

The celebrity edition benefits from casting people who are already familiar with the camera. Many arrive with experience navigating alliances, handling confrontations and understanding how to use their personalities to control a room. Others are actors, who know how to play a character, which makes lying all the more fun and at times, easier for them.

The Celebrity Cast Tends To Be More Comfortable Navigating The Game

The celebrity casts also tend to have fewer reservations about making big moves, even when those decisions create enemies. The civilian edition has a different dynamic. Some contestants appear more hesitant to take risks, challenge their fellow players or make the kind of ruthless decisions that can turn an ordinary episode into must-watch television.

This is likely because the stakes are higher for the civilians. For them, the prize money is life-changing and can help them through some serious struggles that financial stress often brings about. These civilians build bonds with one another, and play with their emotions in a way that the celebs don’t.

However, Season 2 needs a cast that understands this isn’t a friendship retreat. It’s a competition in which trust can be a dangerous thing. Producers should be looking for people who aren’t afraid to lie, manipulate and make unpopular decisions if it means getting closer to the prize money.

The audience doesn’t need everyone to be a villain, but it does need contestants who are willing to play the game, much like Victor from Season 1. Victor was ruthless in his pursuit of the people he believed to be Traitors, and even turned on one of his closest friends in the castle before the finale.

The Celebrity Edition Has Set A Pretty High Bar

It’s difficult to introduce a new version of The Traitors without comparisons to the Peacock series. The celebrity edition has become famous for its larger-than-life personalities and unpredictable social dynamics. Viewers tune in to see who will turn on their friends, which alliances will collapse and who will make a spectacularly bad decision at the roundtable.

The best moments often come when contestants realize that someone they trusted has been manipulating them all along. That’s the kind of television that makes the franchise so addictive.

New Blood has the same basic ingredients, but it hasn’t always produced the same level of chaos. The civilian cast brings a different perspective to the competition, but that doesn’t mean the show should lose the bold personalities and strategic confrontations that viewers associate with the franchise.

In fact, the two versions could complement each other beautifully if producers manage to give each one its own identity while maintaining the same deliciously unpredictable gameplay.

The civilian edition doesn’t need to copy every aspect of the celebrity version. It simply needs to remember that the central attraction is watching people attempt to deceive one another without getting caught.

The Traitors: New Blood stars Katie and Joe
Image: NBC/YouTube

Was Moving The Show To NBC Part Of The Problem?

Casting isn’t necessarily the only issue worth examining before Season 2. Moving the competition to NBC brought a different broadcast environment, including a primetime audience and shorter episodes than viewers are accustomed to seeing with the Peacock edition.

A recent CinemaBlend report raised concerns that the roughly 42 minutes of actual content in an hour-long broadcast slot may not give the show enough room to develop its contestants, strategies and dramatic moments. That’s an important consideration.

After all, viewers need time to understand why certain contestants trust one another, how alliances are developing and what motivates someone to turn against a fellow player. If too much of that gets lost in the editing process, even potentially entertaining contestants can end up feeling less memorable.

Producers should consider whether giving the show more room to breathe would help create the tension and character development that makes the franchise work.

There is a balance to strike between keeping the competition moving and allowing the audience to become invested in the people playing it.

Season 2 Has A Chance To Be Even Better

To be fair, NBC has plenty of reasons to be pleased with The Traitors: New Blood. According to the network’s November 19 renewal announcement, the first season has reached more than 23 million viewers across platforms and introduced more than 14 million new viewers to the franchise. An impressive 61% of its audience was watching The Traitors universe for the first time.

Those numbers suggest the civilian experiment has accomplished something important: It has brought an entirely new audience into the franchise. Alan Cumming is also returning to host Season 2, which is another reason to look forward to the next installment.

However, attracting new viewers and keeping longtime fans entertained are two different challenges. NBC shouldn’t assume that the renewal means there is nothing left to improve. The franchise has built its reputation on outrageous betrayals, shocking revelations and contestants who are willing to do whatever it takes to survive another night in the castle.

Embed from Getty Images

What Did Fans Think Of Traitors: New Blood?

Season 2 needs to bring more of that energy. Give us Faithfuls who aren’t afraid to challenge the group, Traitors who know how to manipulate their fellow contestants and roundtable discussions that leave everyone questioning who they can trust. Most importantly, give us players who understand that being too nice could be their biggest mistake.

“That’s why I like the celeb one better – they’re there more for the game than the money,” one viewer wrote via Reddit. “First seasons always have kinks to work out,” said another. “Imo, this season was not interesting,” a third person added. “Definitely not one of the best, but certainly watchable.” a fourth comment read.

The Traitors: New Blood has already proved that there is an audience for an all-civilian version of the competition. Now, it’s time to prove that everyday Americans can bring just as much deliciously ruthless reality-TV drama to the castle as the celebrities who came before them.

Author

  • Trevor Joseph

    Trevor is a fan of fantasy series like Game of Thrones and anything in the Star Wars universe. He also loves Sons of Anarchy and anime like Frieren, Naruto, and Jujutsu Kaisen. His previous writing experience includes working for sites such as Fansided and The Nerd Stash.