For years, reality TV fans have watched and wondered if what they’re seeing is actually real, scripted, or influenced by producers. However, Season 35 of Dancing With The Stars is proving that viewers are taking back their power and making a huge difference when it comes to voting for their favorite contestants.
Two weeks in a row, the ABC dance competition has said goodbye to contestants who have had the highest judges’ scores, both with extensive dance backgrounds. Of course, its raising questions about what fans actually want to see from DWTS. On Tuesday, Harry Shum Jr. was eliminated on a night where he received perfect scores for both of his dances.
Are Dancing With The Stars Fans Sending A Message?
The week before, Jenna Dewan was booted from the ballroom following her own set of high scores. The one thing Jenna and Harry have in common, is that they are both former dancers. Both stars worked as dancers before transitioning to acting. Dewan has appeared on stage with singers, in music videos, and even went on tour with the likes of Janet Jackson, Christina Aguilera, Pink, and Missy Elliott.
Meanwhile, Shum Jr. also appeared as a dancer in commercials and music videos, joining famous artists such as Beyoncé, Mariah Carey, and Madonna during his dancing days. It’s made a point that fans might not want to see former professional dancers with the show, and would rather see someone with no dance experience journey from complete beginner to DWTS champion.
Could viewers be pushing back against casting choices they believe give certain celebrities an unfair head start? It’s an interesting possibility, especially considering how much the show has leaned into its fan-voting format over the years.
Fans Have Been Debating the Advantage Since Casting Was Announced
The debate surrounding Dewan and Shum wasn’t something that suddenly appeared after their eliminations. It started when viewers learned that two contestants with professional dance backgrounds would be competing against celebrities with considerably different levels of experience.
There is a reasonable argument on both sides. On one hand, contestants shouldn’t necessarily be penalized for having worked hard to develop a skill before joining the show. Dewan and Shum still had to learn unfamiliar dance styles, work with their professional partners and deliver performances under the pressure of a live competition.
On the other hand, there’s a reason viewers enjoy watching celebrities transform throughout the season. Seeing someone who initially struggles with basic choreography gradually become a confident performer is part of the appeal. When someone enters the ballroom with years of professional dance training, that transformation can feel very different.
And that’s where the casting debate becomes particularly interesting. Fans aren’t necessarily saying experienced dancers can’t learn anything new. They may simply want a competition where contestants start from a more comparable place. The show’s own voting system acknowledges that difference.
In a previous interview with E! News, executive producer Conrad Green explained that judges’ scores and viewer votes each account for 50% of the results. He also described the public vote as a way to help level the playing field when contestants have different backgrounds.
In other words, the audience has always had a mechanism to influence the outcome beyond what happens during the performances.
Harry’s Elimination Made the Conversation Harder to Ignore
If viewers were already questioning the casting balance after Dewan’s departure, Shum’s elimination brought the discussion to another level. The result was especially surprising because Shum had consistently demonstrated the kind of performance ability that made him an early contender.
Co-host Julianne Hough offered one possible explanation after the elimination, suggesting that viewers sometimes assume contestants doing well with the judges’ scores don’t need their votes. That raises another interesting possibility: Could some viewers have been less motivated to vote for contestants they believed were already benefiting from an advantage?
There is no way to know how individual fans voted, and the show doesn’t release the detailed vote totals needed to establish why a particular couple went home. But the question is worth considering when looking at the season’s consecutive eliminations.
There were also other factors surrounding Shum’s departure. His partnership with Johnson became caught up in controversy involving her husband, Val Chmerkovskiy, and judge Carrie Ann Inaba. Chmerkovskiy was suspended for a week after a controversial social media post, creating additional noise around the partnership.
Shum himself later described the season as chaotic and spoke about the negative online environment surrounding the competition. That makes it difficult to attribute his elimination to one particular issue.
Are Viewers Rewriting the Rules of Reality TV?
The interesting thing about Dancing With the Stars is that the audience has never been asked to judge contestants solely on their technical ability.
Personality, likability, improvement, partnerships and emotional connections have always played a part in the competition. But that doesn’t mean viewers have to agree with the casting decisions or the way the competition unfolds.
In fact, the consecutive exits of Dewan and Shum highlight an ongoing tension in reality television. Producers want recognizable contestants who can deliver impressive performances, while audiences often want to see ordinary people pushed outside their comfort zones and transformed by the experience.
Those two goals don’t always fit together. And perhaps that’s the message viewers are sending, whether intentionally or not. It would be unfair to claim that fans collectively organized to eliminate Dewan and Shum because of their dance backgrounds. Their voting decisions aren’t public, and neither elimination can be explained with certainty.
However, the controversy surrounding their experience shows that casting choices can influence how audiences approach a competition long before the final votes are counted.
With the season 35 finale approaching on November 24, the question isn’t simply who will win the Mirrorball Trophy. It’s whether Dancing With the Stars has found the right balance between celebrity talent, genuine improvement and giving viewers a competition they believe is fair.
After all, if fans are going to be asked to decide the winners, they may also expect producers to listen when they have something to say about the contestants competing in the first place.
One this is for certain, Jenna Dewan and Harry Shum Jr.’s exits before the finale have deprived viewers of what likely would have been some amazing freestyle dances.



